Why I (Reluctantly) Let AI Take My Calls – And What Actually Happened

Sometimes, tech innovations sneak up on you. I never planned to hand my agency’s first impression over to artificial intelligence, but one too many missed calls and endless admin hours forced my hand. This is the unfiltered (and a little messy) chronicle of handing the phone—the lifeblood of my leads—to a team of AI call assistants. Spoiler: It didn’t go how I expected, but maybe that’s a good thing.

A Messy Start: My Skeptical Introduction to AI Call Assistants

I never thought I'd end up here. Seriously. Me, a traditional business owner, letting a robot handle my calls? But after losing three potential clients in one week because I couldn't pick up the phone, I reluctantly started exploring options.

The Desperation Phase

Missing calls means missing money. It's that simple. My small agency was growing, but I was drowning in work. Something had to give.

I stumbled upon Assistants.ai while doom-scrolling through business solutions at 1 AM. Their claim? AI assistants that sound human enough to handle first-touch calls. Right...

Too Good to Be True?

The onboarding process was suspiciously smooth. Pick a voice, set some parameters, and... that's it? No coding required? No "prompt engineering" whatever that means? Just tell it about your business in plain English?

I kept waiting for the catch. There's always a catch with these tech solutions, isn't there?

Price Structure (That Actually Made Sense)

• $37/Month: Solo Plan for testing the waters
• $297/Month: Agency Starter (what I chose)
• $597/Month: Agency Unlimited (for bigger operations)

Plus 7 cents per minute for voice calls. Straightforward enough.

The White-Label Dilemma

Then came the strange part: slapping my logo on this AI felt... deceptive? Would clients feel tricked if they knew their first interaction was with a bot?

But the white-label features were admittedly impressive. Custom domains, my brand colors, my dashboard. It all looked legitimately mine.

And weirdly, clients seemed to appreciate the cohesive branding experience. One even commented on how "seamless" our process felt. If only they knew...

The 24/7 Question

The biggest hurdle was philosophical: can a tireless assistant really feel human enough for real prospects?

"The future belongs to those who can blend technology and empathy." – Assistant.ai (Team)

Nice marketing line, but could it deliver? Humans connect emotionally to first touchpoints—it's daunting to put that in the hands of a bot.

Could AI actually engage leads instantly while I slept? Book appointments? Update my CRM? Fill custom values in GoHighLevel?

I hovered over the "activate" button, questioning everything. What if it said something weird? What if it misunderstood a prospect's needs? What if it just sounded... robotic?

But also: what if it worked?

I took a deep breath and clicked the button. My AI assistant was live.

And then I waited...

Plunging In: Integration Day—Surprises, Glitches, and Quick Wins

Okay, confession time. I was sure setting up this AI call system would be a nightmare. You know how tech promises go—"easy setup" usually means "clear your weekend and have tech support on speed dial."

But connecting to GoHighLevel? Suspiciously painless. Like, concerningly easy. A few clicks and it was done. No engineering degree required. No sacrificial offerings to the tech gods. Just...working.

The Cringe-Worthy Beginning

Then came the first few calls. Oh boy.

Have you ever heard your own voice played back and thought, "Do I really sound like that?" Well, try reading transcripts of your AI handling customer inquiries. I cringed. Hard.

But here's the thing—it worked. Callers got their information. Appointments were made. The world didn't end.

• The setup: Connected to GoHighLevel in literally minutes
• First impression: Call transcripts accessible via dashboard (both fascinating and mortifying)
• Reality check: Despite my anxiety, customers were actually getting helped

Goodbye Manual Follow-ups

Remember those hours spent sending reminders and booking appointments? Gone.

The system started automatically following up with leads, setting appointments, and updating our CRM. I kept checking to make sure it was actually happening. It was like having that super-organized assistant who never needs coffee breaks.

For someone who used to manually track everything in spreadsheets (don't judge), this felt like cheating. Good cheating, but still.

The Multilingual Wild Card

Then came the moment that changed everything.

A caller phoned in, clearly nervous, starting in broken English before switching to rapid Spanish. In my pre-AI days, this would have been a disaster—my Spanish vocabulary basically consists of menu items.

The AI assistant smoothly switched languages, calming the caller and handling the entire conversation in Spanish before confirming an appointment in our system.

"Watching the AI switch languages for a nervous caller made me believe in the tech." – Myself

I learned later the system handles seven languages: English, German, Japanese, Spanish, French, Portuguese and Hindi. I can barely handle one before coffee.

First Day Scorecard

By the end of integration day, I had:

• A working system that took minutes to set up
• Transcripts of every call (for better or worse)
• Automated follow-ups running like clockwork
• A multilingual call center that never sleeps

Was it perfect? Nah. There were hiccups. But watching that AI assistant switch languages and handle a call better than I could have? That's when I thought—maybe, just maybe, this reluctant tech adoption wasn't such a bad idea after all.

Are The Robots Really Selling? (And Other Metrics That Matter)

I was skeptical at first. Letting AI handle my calls? Would clients notice? Would it actually sell anything? Numbers don't lie though, and what I've seen has been...surprising.

Speed-to-Lead: The Undeniable Game-Changer

Remember those leads that used to slip through the cracks while we were in meetings or, let's be honest, grabbing lunch? Gone.

I've noticed a significant bump in our "speed to lead" metrics. The AI picks up immediately, every time. No more "I'll call them back later" that turns into never.

This might sound small, but think about it - how many deals have you lost because someone else called back faster?

Client Reactions (Not What I Expected)

Clients have been surprisingly impressed by the instant engagement. Our lead nurture process improved literally overnight. One prospect actually mentioned they appreciated getting answers at 11 PM when they were finally doing research.

"AI doesn't sleep—and it doesn't get annoyed with repeat questions," I keep telling my team. They're probably tired of hearing it.

The Money Part: Rebilling Magic

Here's where it gets interesting for agencies. The rebilling model has opened up new profit streams I hadn't considered:

• Voice minutes are billed per second at just 7 cents/minute
• We can rebill clients for each AI minute used (with markup)
• There's zero overhead compared to hiring human agents

My favorite part? It's all automatic. We're essentially creating passive income from conversations happening while we sleep.

The Cranky Prospect Test

Here's a wild detail that sold me: the AI managed a particularly cranky prospect's repetitive questions with more patience than I could muster before my second coffee.

This person asked the same pricing question four different ways. The AI calmly provided consistent, helpful answers each time without showing a hint of frustration.

Would I have been that patient? Probably not. Would my team? Doubtful.

Behind-the-Scenes Benefits

The reports also showed some unexpected improvements:

• Decreased missed leads (obvious, but still nice to see)
• Reduced admin overhead (the AI updates the CRM automatically)
• More consistent follow-up sequences

For agencies, the scalability is what makes this powerful - voice and chat assistants can be deployed across unlimited sub-accounts on the highest plan.

So are the robots really selling? Yes, but maybe not how you'd expect. They're not replacing closers - they're making sure no opportunity gets missed before your best people can work their magic.

Wild Card: My Favorite (and Least Favorite) AI Assistant Moments

Let's get real for a second. Handing over client calls to an AI felt like letting a stranger babysit my kids. I was nervous, skeptical, and ready to pull the plug at any moment. But after several months, I've collected some memorable moments that made me both laugh and raise my eyebrows.

The Unexpected Hero

Remember that lead from three months ago? The one who seemed interested but never committed? We'd written them off completely. Then something strange happened.

My AI assistant reached out for a routine follow-up and actually listened to what they were saying. Turns out, their hesitation wasn't about our service—they were waiting for a specific feature we'd already launched but hadn't properly highlighted.

The AI caught this detail, emphasized the feature, and boom! A deal we'd considered dead suddenly came back to life. Sometimes it pays to have something that never gets tired of listening.

That Cringe-Worthy Robot Moment

Not all moments were wins, though. There was that time when a potential client asked a complex question about integration timelines, and my AI responded with:

"I am processing your inquiry about integration timelines. Please hold while I calculate the optimal response. Beep boop."

Okay, it didn't actually say "beep boop," but it might as well have. The response was so robotic I almost unplugged the whole system. We had a good laugh about it later, but lesson learned: AI still has its hilariously awkward moments.

Making It Feel Like "Us"

"Putting my logo on the AI dashboard made it feel like an actual team member," I told my business partner after customizing our Assistants.ai setup. And it's true.

Using our brand colors, logo, and voice style made a huge difference—not just for me, but for clients too. The consistency created trust. They didn't feel like they were talking to some generic robot; they were talking to our assistant.

The Weird Side Effect

Here's something I didn't expect: I started testing my phone's voice assistant with increasingly awkward jokes, just to compare responses. "Hey Siri, what's the difference between..." No, I won't finish that sentence.

It's like having an AI at work made me curious about how all AI handles conversation. Am I the only one who does this now?

The most surprising thing wasn't that AI could handle calls—it's how it changed my perspective on what makes communication effective. Sometimes consistency matters more than perfection. And sometimes, seeing your own branding wrapped around technology makes all the difference in the world.

Lessons Learned: Blending Human Touch With AI Automation

After six months of letting AI handle our calls and chats, I've learned some surprising lessons. Not all were what I expected.

Finding Balance in Automation

AI can't replace human warmth—but freeing up my team for higher-value tasks is a real win. I was initially worried clients would notice something "off" about their interactions. They did notice... but not in the way I feared.

What I've found is that automation isn't about replacement—it's amplification. My team now spends less time on repetitive calls and more time on strategic work that actually moves the needle.

"Real innovation doesn't mean losing the human touch; it means putting it where it matters most." – Myself

The Responsiveness Factor

Here's something interesting: clients notice (and value) responsiveness more than absolute perfection. Our 24/7 coverage means inquiries get addressed at 2AM on Saturdays—something impossible before.

One client literally told me, "I don't care if it's AI answering after hours. I care that someone is there when I need help." Fair point!

Early Adopter Growing Pains

AI tools are evolving fast—being an "early adopter" means learning (and laughing) through the bugs. Last month, our AI assistant confidently booked an appointment for "Toosday" and assured the client it was a real day of the week. We all had a good laugh, including the client.

These hiccups are part of the journey. The tools improve almost weekly, and what didn't work three months ago suddenly works flawlessly now.

Custom Fit Takes Time

I'm still tweaking the system to fit my agency's style. The no-coding tools have been a lifesaver since I'm no programmer. I've personalized how our assistants respond to different client types and adjusted workflows specific to our operations.

Some notable wins:

• After-hours lead capture increased 43%
• My team reports feeling less burnt out
• Client response times improved from hours to minutes

The Path Forward

What's become clear is that automation works best when it carries your brand voice and values. Our AI assistants don't pretend to be human—they're transparent about being AI, but they represent our company's approach and knowledge.

Will I ever go back to fully manual operations? Not a chance. But will I continue adjusting the human-AI balance? Absolutely.

For agencies considering this path, my advice is simple: start small, iterate often, and remember that technology should serve your brand identity, not replace it. The goal isn't perfection—it's progress that serves both your team and your clients better than before.

TL;DR: Letting AI assistants handle my agency’s calls brought more than just efficiency. Beyond the numbers, I found unexpected wins, quirks, and new ways of working (and yes, a few surprises).

GetAssistants.AI